AI Website Design Mistakes: How Vibe Coding Can Undo Your UX and SEO

AI can generate a website page in minutes. That does not mean it understands why the website was designed the way it was.

I recently worked through a website repair project after new pages and edits had been created with an AI coding tool. The output looked polished enough at first glance. There were headings, cards, buttons and plenty of copy. But once I reviewed the full site, the underlying strategy had started to come apart.

The customer journey was harder to follow. Similar information appeared on page after page. Calls to action used conflicting language. Search-focused copy had been replaced with more academic wording. Some URLs no longer supported the original keyword strategy. Custom design work had been removed or overwritten, and several pages no longer felt like they belonged to the same website.

This was not a problem with using AI. It was a problem with asking AI to change a system it had not been taught to understand.

AI can create a page without understanding the website

A professionally designed website is more than a collection of attractive sections. Each page has a purpose within a larger system.

The homepage introduces the business and helps people choose where to go. A service overview helps visitors compare options. Individual service pages answer the questions necessary for one decision. An about page establishes trust without repeating a full biography everywhere. Calls to action reflect the real way someone begins working with the business.

Search strategy is part of that system too. Page topics, headings, internal links, URLs and metadata help search engines understand what each page is about. When one page is rewritten in isolation, it can start competing with another page or lose the language potential customers actually use.

An AI tool can produce clean-looking code and confident copy without recognizing any of those relationships.

Common AI website design mistakes

The problems I found were not dramatic errors like a completely broken homepage. They were smaller decisions repeated across the site, which made the overall experience less clear.

Repeating the same information on every page

Several service pages repeated the provider biography, credentials, process, membership information and general booking instructions. That made each page longer without helping someone make the specific decision that brought them there.

Repetition can feel thorough to the person creating the page. To a visitor, it creates more work. Important details become harder to find because everything is presented as equally important.

Making the copy sound more technical than the customer

Clinical expertise needed to remain accurate and credible, but some of the new language read more like an academic presentation than patient-facing website copy.

Expertise should not require the audience to already be an expert. Clear language does not diminish authority. It helps the right person understand whether a service is relevant, what it may involve and what to do next.

Creating conflicting calls to action

The site began using discovery call, consultation, initial consultation and appointment in ways that made them sound interchangeable. They were not.

When terminology changes from page to page, a visitor has to stop and determine whether the buttons lead to different services or the same next step. That hesitation is a user experience problem and a conversion problem.

Replacing the design system with generic patterns

The generated pages introduced repeated eyebrow headings, small decorative labels, tiny numbers, card-heavy layouts and colors that did not consistently match the established brand.

None of those elements is inherently wrong. The problem was that they appeared because they are common AI-generated design patterns, not because they supported this particular customer journey. The result felt more like a set of separate presentation slides than one cohesive website.

Changing URLs and search intent without a migration plan

Some page slugs and topics no longer matched the original search strategy. Other pages had overlapping subjects and unclear roles.

Changing a URL is not simply renaming a page. Existing links, search visibility and internal navigation all depend on it. A change may require a redirect, updated internal links and a clear decision about which page should rank for a particular search.

Removing custom behavior without understanding its purpose

Interactive sections, responsive spacing and other custom code had been altered or removed. Restoring those experiences required more than pasting the old code back in. Each version had to be compared so that useful new information was not lost in the process.

Why fixing the website took longer than generating the pages

AI made the new pages quickly. Repairing them required careful human judgment.

First, the AI-edited pages were moved into a staging area so they could be reviewed without continuing to disrupt the live customer experience. Then the original site and the edited pages had to be compared section by section.

The repair work included:

  • identifying which custom components and original design decisions had been removed

  • restoring the established UX and visual system

  • separating useful new information from repeated or conflicting copy

  • preserving the provider's clinical language and subject-matter expertise

  • clarifying booking terminology and calls to action

  • correcting page roles, internal links and URL slugs

  • reducing unnecessary reading on service landing pages

  • checking desktop and mobile layouts for spacing, contrast and readability

  • turning one unfocused landing page into a more appropriate search-focused article

This is why repairing a vibe-coded website can take as much time as designing a new one. Generation is fast because it does not have to evaluate what already exists. Remediation is slower because every change has to protect the parts that were working while correcting the parts that were not.

The valuable parts should not be thrown away

The answer was not to delete every AI-assisted contribution and restore the website exactly as it had been.

The new pages contained valuable clinical authorship, expanded service information and details that reflected how the business had evolved. Those additions mattered. They simply needed to be edited and placed within the right structure.

Good website repair is not a battle between the designer's version and the client's version. It is the work of understanding the business intent behind both, then creating one experience that customers can actually use.

How to use AI without undoing your website strategy

AI can be extremely useful for exploring ideas, organizing information, creating an initial outline or helping a team document what it knows. It should not be given unsupervised control over an established website.

Before using AI to change a professional website:

  1. Define the purpose of the page and the customer decision it supports.

  2. Provide the existing design system, voice, approved terminology and page hierarchy.

  3. Identify the primary search topic and the role of related pages.

  4. Work in a staging environment rather than directly on the live site.

  5. Preserve the original page and custom code before making changes.

  6. Have a qualified person review the UX, responsive design, accessibility, copy, links and SEO.

  7. Test the full journey, not just the appearance of one section.

Google does not treat content as good or bad simply because AI was involved. The important questions are whether the content is accurate, original, useful and created for people. Human review still matters, especially for facts, metadata, structured information and anything that affects how customers make a decision.

Your website is a business system

The easiest part of website work is generating more content. The harder and more valuable part is deciding what belongs, what does not, where it should live and how every page supports the next step.

That is the difference between producing a page and protecting a website strategy.

If AI-assisted edits have left your website harder to navigate, inconsistent or unclear, the solution may not be another redesign. It may be a focused audit that identifies what is worth preserving, what is creating friction and what needs to be repaired.

Explore LaBelle Branding website strategy and design services, read more about using AI thoughtfully in digital marketing, or start a conversation about your website.

Next
Next

Digital Transformation Strategy: What Zillennials Understand